Sunday, July 3, 2011

First John Lennon, now Bill Clinton?

Bill Clinton said what?

When I was president, we raised the corporate income-tax rates on corporations that made over $10 million [a year]. It made sense when I did it. It doesn’t make sense anymore – we’ve got an uncompetitive rate. We tax at 35 percent of income, although we only take about 23 percent. So, we SHOULD cut the rate to 25 percent, or whatever’s competitive


What the hell? Is Clinton turning conservative? Cut those corporate tax rates! Make American business more competitive! We don't bring in the revenues when the rates are high anyway!

Maybe. Sort of. He went on to say:

…and eliminate a lot of the deductions so that we still get a FAIR amount, and there’s not so much variance in what the corporations pay.


Ah, so he's not calling for lower taxes: he's offering a trade-off. Lower rates for fewer deductions. Not quite Milton Friedman, maybe. Or maybe it is. What's a flat tax, after all, if not a lower across-the-board rate in exchange for no deductions (other than family members) at all?

Let's argue about this:

  • Yes, Clinton's turning more conservative: otherwise he'd be calling for fewer deductions without lowering the rates.


  • No, Clinton's as lefty as ever: he knows the unbridled ability to borrow money is more important to an activist, nannyist federal government than those higher rates.


  • Yes, because he's acknowledging that tax rates change people's behavior. People aren't just static puppets. Liberals never recognize that.


  • No, he's just spouting a different potential "solution" than everybody else so he can look like he's still super-smart and engaged and dangit if only he was still President!


  • Feh. It's meaningless. He was just talking to hear himself talk.


  • Exactly! He was talking unscripted, which means it's more likely he really meant it, or something close to it!


Via Memeorandum. Cross-posted at Right Wing News.

4 comments:

  1. In the wake of ongoing confessions and testimonials I would have to say nothing would surprise me re. closet Republicans... everybody with half a brain figures it out eventually, no matter how gushing the bleeding (and unthinking) heart

    ReplyDelete
  2. It reveals Clinton's inherent support for the free market. Equal tax rates and no tax credits or subsidies to certain industries or favored political groups is the epitome of the free market principle of Equal Justice Under Law.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Lance I think you are spot on with one of your final points. He's Bill Clinton, and he was just likely talking to hear himself talk. Clinton's one of those guys, he just keeps talking and eventually something similar to a coherent thought comes out.

    ReplyDelete
  4. [...] Must Be Acknowledged US Envoy To Attempt Brokering Peaceful Division Of Sudan BLOGS & STUFF Troglopundit: First John Lennon, Now Bill Clinton? Legal Insurrection: Dems Getting Punchy PowerLine: A Tale Of Two Shutdowns Weekly Standard: [...]

    ReplyDelete